What we believed as children about the soul and the afterlife shapes what we implicitly believe as adults – regardless of what we say we believe now says a study published in the British Journal of Social Psychology.

The study was undertaken by Stephanie Anglin, a doctoral student in psychology at Rutgers’ School of Arts and Sciences.

Stephanie said: “My starting point was, assuming that people have these automatic – that is, implicit or ingrained – beliefs about the soul and afterlife, how can we measure those implicit beliefs?”

Some 348 undergraduate psychology students were asked about their beliefs concerning the soul and afterlife when they were 10 years old, and now. Their answers gave her the students’ explicit beliefs – that is, what the students said they believed now, and what they remembered believing when they were 10.

The students’ implicit beliefs about the soul and the afterlife were close to what they remembered as their childhood beliefs. But those implicit beliefs were often very different from their explicit beliefs – what they said they believed now.

Stephanie compared implicit beliefs by religious affiliation, including believers and non-believers, and found no difference between them.

"That suggests that implicit beliefs are equally strong among religious and non-religious people," she said.

The result did not surprise Stephanie as she was aware of an experiment reported in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology in 2009 in which researchers asked people to sign a contract selling their souls to the experimenter for $2. “Almost nobody signed, even though the researchers told them it wasn’t actually a contract and would be shredded right away,” she said.

Stephanie used a well-known statistical tool, the Implicit Association Test, to gauge subjects’ implicit beliefs about the soul and afterlife. In that test, each subject sees two concept words paired on the top of his or her computer screen – in this case, “soul” paired either with “real” or “fake” to gauge his or her beliefs about the soul; “soul” paired either with “eternal” or “death” to address beliefs about the afterlife. A series of words is then flashed on the screen, and the subject must indicate by pressing a key whether each word fits with the two words on top.

“For example, if you had ‘soul’ and ‘fake’ on your screen, words like ‘false’ or ‘artificial’ would fit into that category, but words like ‘existing’ or ‘true’ would not,” Stephanie explained.

Stephanie concedes that there are limitations to her research, but suggests those limitations provide avenues for future research. She examined her subjects’ implicit and explicit beliefs only about the soul and afterlife, and not about the relationship of those beliefs with beliefs about social or political issues. And she had to rely on her subjects’ memories of what they believed when they were children.

“It would be really useful to have a longitudinal study examining the same ideas,” Stephanie said. “That is, study a group of people over time, from childhood through adulthood, and examine their beliefs about the soul and afterlife as they develop.”

The British Journal of Social Psychology publishes original papers in all areas of social psychology.

The Society publishes 11 academic journal titles in conjunction with our publishing partner Wiley-Blackwell. The British Journal of Health Psychology publishes original research on all aspects of psychology related to health, health-related behaviour and illness across the lifespan. Visit the Wiley online library for more information.

Society members can access via PsychSource, our searchable journals, books and multimedia database, developed in partnership with Wiley-Blackwell. Abstracts are free to all, full-text free to members.